Back in September 2018âs âTrickle-Down Disruption from Retail Malaise (Short Coupons),â we noted a troubled trio of âsales and marketing agencies.â We wrote:
With the âperfect stormâ ⌠of (i) food delivery, (ii) the rise of direct-to-consumer CPG brands, (iii) increased competition from private-brand focused German infiltrators Aldi and Lidl, and (iv) the increasingly app-powered WholeFoods, there are a breed of companies that are feeling the aftershocks. Known as âsales and marketing agenciesâ (âSMAsâ), youâd generally have zero clue about them but for the fact that you probably know someone who is addicted to coupon clipping. Or youâre addicted to coupon clipping. No shame in that, broheim. Anyway, thatâs what theyâre known for: coupons (weâre over-simplifying: they each perform other marketing, retailing, and data-oriented services too). The only other way youâd be familiar is if you have a private equity buddy who is sweating buckets right now, having underwritten an investment in one of three companies that are currently in distress. Enter Crossmark Holdings Inc., Acosta Inc., and Catalina Marketing (a unit of Checkout Holding Corp.). All three are in trouble.
Whatâs happened since?
Catalina Marketing filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy. â
Crossmark Holdings Inc. effectuated an out-of-court exchange transaction, narrowing averting a chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. â
And, as of last week, Acosta Inc. launched solicitation of a prepackaged chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. It will be in bankruptcy in the District of Delaware very very soon. Weâve basically got ourselves an SMA hat-trick. â
đĽ
Before we dive into what the bloody hell happened here â and it ainât pretty â letâs first put some more meat on those SMA bones. In doing so, mea culpa: we WAY over-simplified what Acosta Inc. does in that prior piece. So, what do they do?
Acosta has two main business lines: âSales Servicesâ and âMarketing Services.â In the former, âAcosta assists CPG companies in selling new and existing products to retailers, providing business insights, securing optimal shelf placement, executing promotion programs, and managing back-office order-to-cash and claims deduction management solutions. Acosta also works with clients in negotiations with retailers and managing promotional events.â They also provide store-level merchandising services to make sure sh*t is properly placed on shelves, stocks are right, displays executed, etc. The is segment creates 80% of Acostaâs revenue.
The other 20% comes from the Marketing Services segment. In this segment, âAcosta provides four primary Marketing Services offerings: (i) experiential marketing; (ii) assisted selling and training; (iii) content marketing; and (iv) shopper marketing. Acosta offers clients event-based marketing services such as brand launch events, pop-up retail experiences, mobile tours, large events, and trial/demo campaigns. Acosta also provides Marketing Services such as assisted selling, staffing, associate training, in-store demonstrations, and more. Under its shopping marketing business, Acosta advises clients on consumer promotions, package designs, digital shopping, and other shopper marketing channels.â
In the past, the company made money through commission-based contracts; they are now shifting âtowards higher margin revenue generation models that allow the Company to focus on aligning cost-to-serve with revenue generation to better serve clients and maximize growth.â Whatever the f*ck that means.
Weâre being flip because, well, letâs face it: this company hasnât exactly gotten much right over the last four years so we ought to be forgiven for expressing a glint of skepticism that theyâve now suddenly got it all figured out. Indeed, The Carlyle Group LP acquired the company in 2014 for a staggering $4.75b â a transaction that âranked ⌠among the largest private-equity purchases of that year.â Score for Thomas H. Lee Partners LP(which acquired the company in 2011 from AEA Investors LP for $2b)!! This was after the Washington DC-based private equity firm reportedly lost out on its bid to acquire Advantage Sales & Marketing, a competitor which just goes to show the fervor with which Carlyle pursued entry into this business. Now they must surely regret it. Likewise, the company: nearly all of the companyâs $3b of debt stems from that transaction. The companyâs bankruptcy papers make no reference to management fees paid or dividends extracted so itâs difficult to tell whether Carlyle got any bang whatsoever for their equity buck.*
Suffice it to say, this isnât exactly a raging success story for private equity (calling Elizabeth Warren!). Indeed, since 2015 â almost immediately after the acquisition â the company has lost $631mm of revenue and $193mm of EBITDA. It gets worse. Per the company:
âRevenue contributions from the top twenty-five clients in 2015 have declined at approximately 14.6 percent per year since fiscal year 2015. Furthermore, adjusted EBITDA margins have decreased year-over-year since fiscal year 2015 from over 19 percent to approximately 16 percent as of the end of fiscal year 2018.â
When youâre losing this money, itâs awfully hard to service $3b of debt. Not to state the obvious. But why did the companyâs business deteriorate so quickly? Disruption, baby. Disruption. Per the company:
Acostaâs performance was disrupted by changes in consumer behavior and other macroeconomic trends in the retail and CPG industries that had a significant impact on the Companyâs ability to generate revenue. Specifically, consumers have shifted away from traditional grocery retailers where Acosta has had a leadership position to discounters, convenience stores, online channels, and organic-focused grocers, where Acosta has not historically focused.
Just like we said a year ago. Letâs call this âThe Aldi/Lidl/Amazon/Dollar Tree Effect.â Other trends have also taken hold: (a) people are eating healthier, shying away from center-store (where all the Campbellâs, Kelloggâs, KraftHeinz and Nestle stuff is â by the way, those are, or in the case of KraftHeinz, were, all major clients!); and (b) the rise of private label.
Moreover, according to Acosta, consumer purchasing has declined overall due to the increased cost of food (huh? uh, sure okay). The company adds:
These consumer trends have exposed CPG manufacturers to significant margin pressure, resulting in a reduction in outsourced sales and marketing spend. In the years and months leading to the Petition Date, several of Acostaâs major clients consolidated, downsized, or otherwise reduced their marketing budgets.
By way of example, here is Kraft Heinzâ marketing spend over the last several years: